If you're putting less than 20% down, your credit score decides most of this. I ran one $350,000 house and one buyer with 3.5% down through both loans. At a 760 score, conventional cost about $66 a month less than FHA. At a 640 score, FHA cost about $173 a month less. The two came out about the same at around a 720 score. The loan with the lower monthly payment isn't always the cheaper one, because FHA adds an upfront fee of 1.75% and its mortgage insurance usually stays for the life of the loan.
The full video runs through every step. This page has the same figures written out.
Why do two loans on the same house cost different amounts?
The two loans are FHA and conventional, and both charge mortgage insurance when you put less than 20% down. What matters is how each one sets the price of that insurance.
On FHA, the government insures the loan through HUD, the Department of Housing and Urban Development. HUD charges almost everyone the same yearly price no matter their credit score.
On conventional, a private mortgage insurance company takes the risk. It sets your price the way a car insurance company does, based on your track record, which here means your credit score.
I call that FHA's one price rule, because everyone pays the same price on FHA while conventional prices each buyer on their own record. So the real question is whether your credit score gets you a conventional price that's lower or higher than FHA's one price.
What house and buyer did I use?
They're buying a $350,000 house, and they've saved $12,250 for the down payment, which is 3.5%. For most people, $12,250 is a year or more of savings, so I'm keeping it the same on both loans.
That 3.5% is FHA's minimum down payment. Conventional can go a little lower for first-time buyers, but using the same $12,250 on both means the only thing that changes is the loan. My down payment guide covers how much cash each option takes.
Either way, the loan is $337,750. I'll use a 7.4% rate on both, which was Freddie Mac's weekly average for the week of October 8, 2026. Taxes and homeowner's insurance would be the same on both, so I left them out and compared only the loan and its mortgage insurance.
What does each loan cost per month?
Only FHA has an upfront fee. It's 1.75% of the loan, which here is about $5,911. Most people roll it into the loan, and that makes the FHA loan bigger. Principal and interest comes out to about $2,379 a month on FHA and about $2,339 on conventional, so the upfront fee adds about $40 to every payment.
FHA's yearly premium for most buyers with less than 5% down is 0.55% of the loan. That works out to about $155 a month, and it shrinks a little each year as you pay down the balance. So FHA is about $2,534 a month whether your score is 760 or 640.
Conventional depends on your score, so I used one insurer's published rates at three scores.
| Credit score | Insurance on conventional | Conventional | FHA |
|---|---|---|---|
| 760 or higher | $129 | $2,468 | $2,534 |
| 700 to 719 | $222 | $2,561 | $2,534 |
| 640 to 659 | $369 | $2,707 | $2,534 |
So by the month, a 760 score makes conventional about $66 cheaper. At 700, FHA is about $27 cheaper, and at 640, FHA is about $173 cheaper.
In this example, the two loans cost about the same each month at around a 720 score.
If anything, this example leans toward conventional, because in real life the mortgage insurance usually costs a bit more than what I used. Lenders often charge more on conventional loans for lower credit scores, and FHA rates tend to run a little lower.
The monthly payment only tells you half of it, because these two insurance bills don't last the same amount of time.
How long does FHA mortgage insurance last?
On FHA today, with less than 10% down, the yearly premium stays for the whole life of the loan. With 10% or more down, it ends after 11 years.
It wasn't always that way, and the change goes back to a $16 billion hole in FHA's insurance fund.
Starting in 2001, FHA's monthly premium came off on its own once your balance dropped to 78% of the home's original price, as long as you'd been paying it for at least five years. That's a lot like conventional insurance.
Then the 2008 crash hit, and the loans FHA had insured in those years started going bad. By November 2012, the yearly review of FHA's insurance fund came back at negative $16.3 billion, when the law says that fund is supposed to hold a cushion of 2%.
Carol Galante ran the FHA. In February 2013 she sat in front of the House Financial Services Committee to explain what they were going to do. She said FHA had been canceling those premiums since 2001, but "FHA remains responsible for insuring 100% of the unpaid principal balance of a loan for the entire life of the loan."
In other words, buyers could stop paying for the insurance while FHA kept carrying all of the risk. Her office figured 10 to 12% of all of FHA's claim losses would happen after the premiums had already stopped.
FHA sent lenders a letter on January 31, 2013, and starting that June the premium on loans with less than 10% down stays for the life of the loan. That September FHA still took about $1.7 billion from the US Treasury, the first time in its 79 years.
The fund recovered, and in 2023 HUD cut the yearly price to the 0.55% I'm using here. The life of the loan rule stayed. So that's why the FHA premium on this buyer's loan never comes off on its own.
When does conventional mortgage insurance come off?
Conventional insurance is built to come off. Under federal rules, you can ask to cancel it once your balance is scheduled to hit 80% of the home's original value, and it has to end automatically at 78%.
On this loan, making normal payments, it's almost 12 years to ask and about 12 and three quarter years for it to drop off on its own.
It can come off sooner if your home value rises, because Fannie Mae lets you ask to remove it based on what your home is worth now. Between 2 and 5 years into the loan, you'll need to owe 75% or less of that value. After 5 years, it's 80% or less.
If prices rose about 3% a year, which is just an example and nobody can promise it, this buyer could get there right around year five. If prices stay flat, it takes until about year 12.
With less than 10% down, FHA has no version of that. The only ways out of the premium are selling the house or refinancing into a conventional loan.
What does each loan cost over five years?
There's a reason I picked five years. Every Loan Estimate, which is the official form a lender gives you when you apply, has a line on page three called "In 5 Years." So five years is the time frame lenders already show you.
For FHA, I'm counting the full $5,911 upfront fee, because even when it's rolled into the loan, you still owe it. Add about $9,050 of monthly premiums over those five years, and FHA's insurance costs about $14,960.
| Credit score | Conventional | FHA |
|---|---|---|
| 760 or higher | $7,770 | $14,960 |
| 700 to 719 | $13,340 | $14,960 |
| 640 to 659 | $22,120 | $14,960 |
At 760, conventional saves about $7,200 over five years, and at 640, FHA saves about $7,200.
At 700, conventional comes out about $1,600 ahead even though FHA had the lower monthly payment. The reason is that upfront fee, because it's added to what you owe. So FHA can look cheaper each month and still cost more over time.
What happens after year five?
Take the buyer with a 700 score. If home prices go up, you build equity faster, and the conventional mortgage insurance can come off around year five while FHA keeps charging you every month. By year 10, conventional comes out about $10,000 ahead.
If prices stay flat, the conventional insurance doesn't come off that early, and by year 10 FHA comes out about $3,300 ahead.
So in the middle of the score range, the answer comes down to how long you keep the loan and what prices do.
When does FHA win?
- Your score is under about 700, at least in an example like this one. The insurer table I used doesn't even go below 620, while FHA allows 3.5% down from a 580 score.
- Your debts are high compared to your income. Fannie Mae's automated system for conventional loans tops out when your monthly debts reach 50% of your income, while FHA's system can approve you up to about 57% on a strong file. If you're close to 50%, FHA may be the one that gets you approved.
- You've had a bankruptcy. FHA's waiting period after a Chapter 7 discharge is two years, and Fannie Mae's standard wait is four.
- The seller is paying your closing costs. At this down payment, a seller can put up to 6% of the price toward your costs on FHA and 3% on conventional.
When does conventional win?
- Your score is around 740 or higher. It's cheaper by the month and over time.
- You have a bigger down payment. At 20% down, conventional usually has no mortgage insurance at all, while FHA still charges a yearly premium of 0.5% for 11 years.
- The price of the house is high. FHA has a county loan limit, starting at $541,287 in lower-cost areas in 2026. Above it, conventional is the one that works.
- You plan to stay a while and home values rise. The conventional insurance can come off, and the FHA premium with less than 10% down doesn't.
Should you take FHA now and refinance into conventional later?
A lot of FHA buyers are told to do that to get rid of the insurance. It's possible, and it's worth knowing the math before you count on it.
After five years, this FHA loan's balance is about $324,800. If prices rose about 3% a year, the house would be worth about $405,700. You'd owe about 80% of its value, and a conventional refinance without mortgage insurance becomes realistic.
If prices stay flat, you'd still owe about 93% of the home's value, and that refinance doesn't help much.
Even when it works, a refinance is a brand new loan. You apply and qualify again, you pay closing costs again, and the rate on the day you want to refinance could be higher than the one you have.
So pick the loan that still makes sense if you never refinance, and treat a refinance as a possible bonus.
How do you check this on a house you're really buying?
When you get pre-approved, ask for an FHA and a conventional Loan Estimate on the same day. Then compare the monthly payment on page one and the "In 5 Years" line on page three.
Your credit score and how long you keep the loan decide which loan costs less.
Common questions about FHA and conventional loans
Is FHA or conventional better for a first-time buyer?
It mostly depends on your credit score. In my example, a $350,000 house with 3.5% down, the two loans cost about the same each month at around a 720 score. At 760, conventional was about $66 a month cheaper. At 640, FHA was about $173 a month cheaper.
What credit score do you need for FHA and for conventional?
FHA allows 3.5% down from a 580 score. The conventional mortgage insurance table I used doesn't go below 620. Conventional gets cheaper as your score goes up, and around 740 or higher it's cheaper by the month and over time.
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
With less than 10% down, the yearly premium stays for the whole life of the loan. With 10% or more down, it ends after 11 years. Otherwise the only ways out are selling the house or refinancing into a conventional loan.
When does mortgage insurance come off a conventional loan?
You can ask to cancel it once your balance is scheduled to hit 80% of the home's original value, and it has to end automatically at 78%. It can come off sooner if your home value rises. Between 2 and 5 years into the loan you need to owe 75% or less of the current value, and after 5 years 80% or less.
What is the FHA upfront mortgage insurance fee?
It's 1.75% of the loan, and only FHA has it. On a $337,750 loan that is about $5,911. Most people roll it into the loan, which added about $40 to every payment in my example.
Should I take FHA now and refinance into conventional later?
It's possible, and it depends on home prices. If prices rose about 3% a year, the buyer in my example would owe about 80% of the home's value after five years and a refinance becomes realistic. If prices stay flat, they'd still owe about 93%. A refinance is a new loan with new closing costs and that day's rate, so pick the loan that still makes sense if you never refinance.
How do I compare FHA and conventional on my own house?
When you get pre-approved, ask for an FHA and a conventional Loan Estimate on the same day. Then compare the monthly payment on page one and the "In 5 Years" line on page three.