What are the red flags when buying a house?

By Luke Shankula, mortgage educator and host of Mortgages Made Simple. Published November 18, 2026.

Of the ten problems on this list, most turn out to be a negotiation. The five the loan can catch are a roof near the end of its life, a moving foundation, active termites, a failed septic system and unsafe wiring. A normal inspection doesn't have to check five of the ten, and the one I'd walk away from completely is an old heating oil tank that may have leaked. What matters on any of them is whether you can get a written price for the fix and still have money left after closing.

The full video runs through every step. This page has the same figures written out.

Which red flags can stop the loan, and which can I negotiate?

These are ten problems that could be called dealbreakers, and most of them turn out to be a negotiation. A normal inspection doesn't have to check five of the ten, and one of the big inspector groups says so in its own published standards.

The last one is the one I'd walk away from completely. It's the reason a buyer in Massachusetts got a letter from the state about a spill from 10 years before she even bought the house.

Is a roof near the end of its life a red flag?

It can cause trouble with your loan and your insurance. Your mortgage lender sends an appraiser to figure out what the house is worth. On an FHA loan, the government-backed loan with 3.5% down, that appraiser also has to look at the roof. Right now FHA wants at least 2 years of life left on it. If the roof looks like it has less, a professional roofer has to go inspect it. The appraiser's report gets marked subject to, which means the loan doesn't go through until the roof is handled.

VA loans for veterans and regular conventional loans don't set a number of years. They care more about whether the roof keeps water out and whether the damage affects the safety or the structure. On any of these loans, a bad enough roof can hold up your closing day, the day you sign the papers and get the keys.

The appraiser's report doesn't make the seller pay for the roof, because your contract decides who pays for it.

The second problem with an old roof is homeowners insurance. Your mortgage lender won't close without a policy, and an old roof can cause trouble with that policy. In Texas, for example, an insurance company can cancel a brand new policy in the first 60 days. One reason it can cancel is finding out about a risk you didn't mention, like that old roof. So call for an insurance quote during your inspection period, which is the days your contract gives you to back out of the deal. Give them the real age of the roof.

Isn't the appraiser already checking the whole house for me?

No. In 1996, Frank and Shannon Gaglio paid $85,000 for a house in Penns Grove, New Jersey with an FHA loan. After they moved in, Frank found termite damage in a support beam, a roof that needed replacing, and sewer gas coming into the upstairs bathroom. The appraiser hadn't reported on any of it. Frank said, "The appraiser seemed to follow three rules. See no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil." When he applied for a repair loan, he got turned down because the repairs would have cost him more than the house was worth.

Today, on an FHA loan, your mortgage lender has to hand you a form that says appraisals are not home inspections. The appraiser and the inspector work like the two checks on a used car you buy with a loan. The bank checks that the car is worth what it's lending, and your own mechanic tells you if the transmission is about to go. The appraiser is the bank in that story, and the inspector you hire is your mechanic.

Is a foundation that's moving a red flag?

This is one of the hardest problems to put a price on. FHA says the foundation has to last for the life of the loan, and a bulging wall or a cracked foundation can trigger an inspection by a specialist.

I'd hire a structural engineer, someone who isn't selling the repair. Get it in writing whether the foundation is still moving and what the fix is. A foundation that's still moving with nobody willing to price the fix is a different problem.

Are active termites a red flag?

With termites that are still active, the bugs are the cheap part. FHA wants the house free of wood destroying insects. On a VA loan, termites or damage that shows up has to be fixed before closing. Treatment runs about $250 to about $1,000. Repairing the damage averages about $3,000 and it can reach up to about $10,000.

A normal home inspection doesn't have to look for them, so pay for a pest inspection as well. If a contractor has looked at the wood and given you a price, I wouldn't run from this one. These loans give you no room at all.

Is a failed septic system a red flag?

Some houses have a septic system in place of a city sewer. If it isn't working and there's no public sewer to connect to, FHA says the mortgage lender has to reject the house, and that stands until it's repaired or replaced.

If the house you want to buy has a septic system, order a septic inspection and write it into your contract that the seller pays for any repairs. A new system averages about $8,000.

Is unsafe wiring a red flag?

It's usually a smaller bill than it sounds, with one big exception. An FHA appraiser has to look for frayed or exposed wires. They also report an electrical panel, the breaker box, that looks too small for the house. A new panel costs about $1,600, so I'd ask the seller to cover it and move on.

The big exception is an old kind of wiring called knob and tube, which you'll find in very old houses. It averages about $24,300 to replace, and it can make insurance harder to get.

That's five problems the loan can catch.

Should I hire my own inspector instead of one my agent recommends?

You can, because you're the one paying. Ask to see a sample report first, which is what FHA's own form for buyers tells you to do.

Even your own inspector doesn't have to check everything on this list. InterNACHI, one of the big inspector groups, publishes what its inspectors have to check. I'm counting radon and asbestos as one item, and that makes five of the ten.

What an inspector isn't required to check, per InterNACHI's published standards
Not requiredOn this list
PestsTermites (#3)
Septic systemsSeptic system (#4)
Underground pipesSewer line (#6)
Radon and asbestosRadon and asbestos (#9)
Underground tanksOil tank (#10)

You can get a clean inspection report on a house with termites, a failed septic system, a broken sewer line and a leaking oil tank. To find those, you have to pay for extra checks. The last of those is the one I would walk away from.

Is a bad sewer line a red flag?

An inspector doesn't have to look inside the sewer line from the house out to the street. A plumber can run a camera through it for about $300 to $400. The average replacement is about $3,300. It's priced by the foot, so a long run can get into the tens of thousands.

If the house is older or has big trees out front, that camera is the cheapest move on this whole list.

Are water and mold a red flag?

Mold is usually how you find out about water getting into the house. Cleaning up mold averages about $2,400, but it comes back if the water keeps coming. So make a contractor tell you where the water's coming from and get a written price to stop it.

Is an old furnace or air conditioner a red flag?

This is where I disagree with a lot of the advice on YouTube. Plenty of these lists say to walk away, and I think that's too much. FHA's own handbook says the appraiser shouldn't ask to replace something that's still working just because of its age.

A new system averages about $7,500. I treat it as a bill to plan for and ask the seller to help.

A home warranty won't save you on this one, because Consumer Reports warns that those contracts often leave out problems that were already there.

Are radon and asbestos red flags?

They sound like the scariest ones on this list. For me, neither of these is a dealbreaker by itself.

Radon is a gas you can't see or smell that raises your risk of lung cancer, and the EPA estimates nearly one in 15 homes has a level high enough that it says to fix it. The fix averages about $1,000. So test for radon and ask the seller to fix it or cover the cost.

Asbestos is a mineral fiber that used to be common in building materials. The EPA says the best thing is usually to leave it alone if it's in good condition, so it mostly turns into a bill when you plan to remodel.

Is an old heating oil tank a red flag?

This is the one I'd walk away from. It's an old heating oil tank, often buried in the yard, that may have leaked. A normal inspection doesn't have to look for one, so it's on you to ask.

A homeowner in Blackstone, Massachusetts, bought her house in 2017. The next year, the state sent her a letter saying she was responsible for the cleanup of a spill from 2007, two owners before her. Just testing the soil started at $14,000 and the total could reach six figures, and her insurance company denied the claim. The state held off on forcing the cleanup while she filed hardship paperwork, but the spill was still on her property.

If the seller offers you money to cover it, that doesn't solve this one. That's a set amount of money, and nobody can tell you what a cleanup costs until they've dug it up.

Look for a small fill pipe sticking out of the yard or an old oil line in the basement. If you see one, pay for a tank scan before you close. If the scan comes back clean, or the seller removes a tank and gives you the state's paperwork, you're totally fine. If the tank leaked and nobody will give you the price, I'd walk, even if the seller's offering you a lot of money.

Repair and check costs from the list, national averages from Angi
ProblemCost
TermitesTreatment about $250 to $1,000, damage repair about $3,000 and up to about $10,000
Septic systemNew system about $8,000
Electrical panelAbout $1,600
Knob and tube wiringAbout $24,300 to replace
Sewer lineCamera about $300 to $400, replacement about $3,300
MoldCleanup about $2,400
Furnace or air conditionerNew system about $7,500
RadonFix about $1,000
Oil tankSoil testing alone starts at $14,000, and the total could reach six figures

Repair costs are national averages from Angi, and yours will vary.

What does a $15,000 roof do to my savings?

Say you're buying a $320,000 house with an FHA loan. You need $20,800 in cash for the down payment and the closing costs, which are the fees to finish the purchase. Say you've saved $33,000, which for most people takes a few years. That leaves you $12,200 in the bank after closing. Any repair bill comes out of it.

Now say the roof has about 3 years left, and a roofer quotes $15,000 to replace it. The roof passes FHA's 2-year rule, so the loan goes through, but that $15,000 bill is coming within about 3 years. Right now you've only got about $12,200 saved up.

Should I ask the seller for a price cut or a credit?

If you ask for a price cut, your down payment only drops by 3.5% of the $15,000. That's $525. The rest of the $15,000 just makes the loan smaller, and your payment drops about $118 a month. Even with the price cut, the money in your bank doesn't cover the roof. You come up about $2,300 short.

The better way to ask for that same $15,000 is a seller credit, where the seller pays your closing costs for you. Every dollar of that is a dollar you don't have to bring on closing day. A credit can't be bigger than your actual closing costs, which here are about $9,600. So you take $9,600 as a credit and the other $5,400 off the price. The seller is still giving up the same $15,000.

Your down payment barely moves and your closing costs are covered. You start with $33,000 and only about $11,000 leaves at closing. That leaves about $22,000. After the $15,000 roof, you've still got about $7,000 left over, instead of coming up $2,300 short. That's more than $9,000 extra in cash.

The same $15,000 from the seller, asked for two ways
Price cutSeller credit
Effect on the down paymentDrops by $525Barely moves
Monthly paymentDrops about $118About $75 more than the price cut
Cash after the $15,000 roofAbout $2,300 shortAbout $7,000 left

The catch is a higher payment, about $75 more than the price cut. The price cut gives most of that $15,000 back slowly as smaller payments over 30 years. The credit keeps the cash in your bank for when the roof bill shows up. That $75 a month would take about 10 years to add up to the cash you kept. So if cash is tight, I take the credit, and with plenty of savings, the price cut is fine.

If the seller would rather do the roof before closing, that can work too, and it leaves your whole $12,200. The risk is that the seller is picking the roofer. So write into the contract a licensed roofer, the permit, a paid invoice, and a warranty you can use. If the seller will put all that in writing, I'd let the seller do the work. If not, take the credit.

There's a second limit on a seller credit, and it depends on your loan. FHA allows up to 6% of the price, so your $9,600 fits. Conventional and VA loans have their own limits. The wording can also cost you cash. On FHA, if your contract calls that money a repair allowance, your mortgage lender takes it off the price, which makes it work more like the price cut. So have the credit written toward your closing costs and have your mortgage lender read that line before you sign.

If the appraiser already flagged the roof, a credit doesn't get you out of that. The roof still has to be handled before closing.

What if I don't have cash left after closing?

Plenty of buyers won't have $12,200 left after closing. The seller credit matters even more for you. On this house, it drops the cash you need at closing from $20,800 to about $11,000.

FHA also has a loan called a limited 203k. It rolls up to $75,000 of repairs, including a new roof, into your mortgage when you buy the house. The work can't be structural, so a foundation that's moving wouldn't fit. Ask your mortgage lender what else counts. Conventional loans have a version called HomeStyle, and both take more paperwork. Ask your mortgage lender about them before you close.

Remember Frank, with the termites and the sewer gas? He applied for FHA's 203k program after he already owned the house, and that's when he got turned down. So price your repairs before closing, while you can still walk away.

When would I walk away from a house?

Most older houses have some of these problems. Here's when I'd walk:

  • When nobody will put a written price on the fix, like the oil tank or a foundation that's still moving.
  • When the loan can't close until something's fixed and the seller won't do it.
  • When the fix is bigger than what you'd have left, the seller won't move, and you can't roll it into the loan.

Everything else on this list is a negotiation. You can only walk if your contract gives you an inspection period, so I wouldn't give that up to win a house. Every report is going to have something on it. What matters is whether you can get a written price and still have money left after closing.

What should I remember about these red flags?

Your loan can stop the deal over the roof, the foundation, active termites, a failed septic system or unsafe wiring. During your inspection period, pay for the extra checks on pests, septic, the sewer line, mold, radon, and any old oil tank.

If the seller offers you that $15,000 and cash is tight, take it as a credit first, up to your closing costs, and take the rest off the price, so a $15,000 offer doesn't turn into $525 on closing day.

Common questions about red flags when buying a house

What are the biggest red flags when buying a house?

In this list, the five the loan can catch are the roof, a moving foundation, active termites, a failed septic system and unsafe wiring. The one I would walk away from is an old heating oil tank that may have leaked. Most of the rest turn out to be a negotiation.

Does a normal inspection check everything on this list?

No. A normal inspection doesn't have to check five of the ten. InterNACHI, one of the big inspector groups, publishes that its inspectors aren't required to check for pests, septic systems, underground pipes, underground tanks, or radon and asbestos. You can get a clean report on a house with termites, a failed septic system, a broken sewer line and a leaking oil tank.

Does the appraiser check the house for problems?

The appraiser works for the bank and checks that the house is worth what the bank is lending. Your inspector is your mechanic. On an FHA loan, your lender has to hand you a form that says appraisals are not home inspections.

Should I ask the seller for a price cut or a seller credit?

If cash is tight, I take the credit first, up to your closing costs, and take the rest off the price. In my example, a $15,000 price cut only dropped the down payment by $525 and left the buyer about $2,300 short after the roof. A $9,600 credit plus $5,400 off the price left about $7,000 in the bank.

What if I do not have cash left after closing?

The seller credit matters even more. FHA also has a loan called a limited 203k that rolls up to $75,000 of repairs, including a new roof, into your mortgage when you buy. The work can't be structural. Conventional loans have a version called HomeStyle, and both take more paperwork.

When would you walk away from a house?

I'd walk when nobody will put a written price on the fix, like an oil tank or a foundation that's still moving. I'd also walk when the loan can't close until something's fixed and the seller won't do it, or when the fix is bigger than what you'd have left, the seller won't move and you can't roll it into the loan.

Should I give up my inspection period to win a house?

I wouldn't. You can only walk if your contract gives you an inspection period. Every report is going to have something on it. What matters is whether you can get a written price and still have money left after closing.

Sources

The figures in this guide come from the video above, which uses these sources.

More guides

See all guides

Luke Shankula

Luke Shankula is a mortgage educator in San Diego and the host of Mortgages Made Simple on YouTube, Instagram and TikTok. He co-founded Cadre Mortgage Group with Rebecca Richardson and Marissa Dropulic. He has held his mortgage license since 2017 (NMLS #1446932). More about Luke