Renting vs buying a home: who has more money after 20 years?

By Luke Shankula, mortgage educator and host of Mortgages Made Simple. Published November 18, 2026.

I ran this comparison on the worst month to buy a house in the last 40 years, July 2006. Twenty years later the buyer walked away with about $274,000. A renter who invested every dollar they saved by not buying finished with about $657,000, a renter who invested half finished with about $349,000, and a renter who invested none of it finished with about $41,500. To tie the buyer, a renter had to invest about 38 cents of every dollar they saved by renting and keep it going for 20 years.

The full video runs through every step. This page has the same figures written out.

How did I run the comparison?

I used real home prices, the government rent data and the stock market, and the data runs up to July 2026.

You're the buyer in this story. In July 2006 you paid about $230,000 for a typical house. Over the next five and a half years, home prices fell 27%. It took more than 10 years for that house to get back to what you paid.

The person next door rented the same kind of house. I used three different renters, because real renters don't all do the same thing with the money they save by not buying.

  • The all-in renter invests all of it.
  • The half renter invests half of it.
  • The no stocks renter invests none of it.

For the investing, I used the S&P 500 with dividends. I'm not telling you what to invest in. Whatever a renter doesn't invest from the upfront cash sits in a savings account, and whatever they don't invest from the monthly savings gets spent on regular life.

What did the house really cost every month?

Say you put 10% down and paid closing costs, the fees to finish the purchase. You needed $29,900 in cash, and it takes most people years to save that.

You borrowed the rest at 6.76%, the average 30-year rate that month. Your loan payment came out to $1,344 a month, and that payment stays the same for 30 years.

July 2006, buyer and renter next door
CostAmount
Price of the houseAbout $230,000
Cash needed (10% down plus closing costs)$29,900
Loan payment at 6.76%$1,344 a month
Whole cost to own (adds taxes, insurance, repairs, mortgage insurance)About $1,879 a month
Rent on a similar houseAbout $1,056 a month
Extra the buyer spends, after the tax break and renter's insuranceAbout $580 a month

So the renter starts with that $29,900 they never had to put down, plus about $580 a month that you're spending and they're not. What they do with that money decides who wins.

What happened when the crash hit?

By February 2012, if you'd had to sell, the house was worth about $26,000 less than what you owed. After the cost of selling it, you would have had to write a check for about $37,000 just to get out. The renter had a lease and could walk away at the end of it.

The renters who invested got hit too, and they got hit first. From October 2007 to February 2009, the stock market fell 51% even with dividends counted. By February 2009 the all-in renter had put in about $47,000 and the account was down to about $28,000. The no stocks renter had about $32,000. The person who invested everything was behind the person who never invested at all.

The renter still had to pay rent, and it kept going up the whole time. Home prices fell for more than five years and the rent went up every single year. By 2015 the rent next door had passed your $1,344 loan payment, which hadn't moved in nine years.

Where did everyone stand after 10 years?

In July 2016 your house was almost back to what you paid. After selling costs and paying off the loan, you'd have walked away with about $35,000.

The no stocks renter had about $33,000. The half renter had about $95,000 and the all-in renter had about $158,000. If the comparison stopped there, the renters who invested win and it isn't close.

The next 10 years are when the buyer starts catching up. From July 2020 to July 2022, home prices jumped almost 39%, which added more than $100,000 to the value of your house in two years. In 2022 the stock market fell about 24% in nine months. In April 2022, almost 16 years after you bought, you passed the half renter for the first time.

That's why a rent versus buy comparison can get a different answer depending on the year somebody runs it.

Who had more money after 20 years?

In July 2026, exactly 20 years after you bought, that $230,000 house was worth about $420,000. Take off about 7% to sell it and the $117,000 you still owed, and that leaves you about $274,000.

Your profit on the house was about $190,000. A single person can keep up to $250,000 of profit on a home tax-free. I charged the renters a 15% tax on their dividends and on their profit from selling the stocks, which they'd owe in a regular investing account.

What each person had after 20 years
PersonAfter 10 yearsAfter 20 years
Buyer (July 2006)About $35,000About $274,000
All-in renterAbout $158,000About $657,000
Half renterAbout $95,000About $349,000
No stocks renterAbout $33,000About $41,500

You beat one of them and you lost to two. The all-in renter finished about $384,000 ahead of you, and the three renters ended up more than $600,000 apart.

How much does a renter have to invest to tie the buyer?

It comes out to about 38 cents of every dollar they save by renting. That's about $11,000 up front and about $220 a month at the start. The monthly amount shrinks as the rent catches up, but they have to keep it going for 20 years, including the months when the account was worth less than what they put in.

Anybody who invested less than those 38 cents lost to a person who bought at the worst possible moment to buy a house.

Even in those 20 years, the renters had some help. Stocks returned a little over 11% a year, and the long run average is about 10%. If stocks had earned that 10%, the half renter would have lost to you. And 10 years from now that $1,344 loan payment goes away for good, while the rent next door keeps going.

Why did a buyer with terrible timing do that well?

Part of it is that the house went up in value. The rest comes from how a mortgage works.

Every month, part of the mortgage payment paid down the loan and you couldn't skip it. It works like retirement money that comes out of your paycheck before you ever see it. That's called forced savings.

The renter's plan is more like a jar on the kitchen counter. The renter has to fill it by hand every single month, including the month their hours get cut or they lose their job.

Over 20 years your mortgage payment paid down about $90,000 you never had to decide to save. Add the $23,000 you put down and the $190,000 the house gained, take off the 7% it cost to sell, and that's your $274,000.

What happens if you buy in any other month?

July 2006 is one starting month, and it's the worst one in the last 40 years. So I ran the same comparison starting in every month from January 1988 to July 2006, each with that month's price, rent and mortgage rate. That's 223 buyers, and I followed each one for 20 years.

  • The no stocks renter never won, not one single time.
  • The half renter won 10 times, and all 10 started in the 10 months leading up to July 2006.
  • The all-in renter won 28 times, and 26 of those started in the two years or so before that peak.

So the buyer beat even the renter who invested every dollar about seven times out of eight. For the stock market, the 20 years in this story were the third best out of all 223, so this was about the best case the renters could get.

Those 223 scenarios cover a lot of the same years, so treat this as a long piece of history. The next 20 years can do something completely different.

How do you run the rent vs buy test on a real listing?

Most of the time you could have known ahead of time who was going to win, by comparing what it costs each month to own the house with what it costs to rent one.

  1. Pull up a real listing you could see yourself buying.
  2. Add up the loan payment, property taxes, insurance and mortgage insurance. Most listing sites already estimate those for you.
  3. Add a monthly amount for repairs, which is about 1% of the price a year divided by 12.
  4. Divide that total by the rent on a similar house.
What the result has meant, 1988 to 2006 buyers
Cost to own divided by rentWhat happened
Under about 1.4The buyer beat all three renters, 156 out of 156 times
Between 1.4 and 1.7It could go either way
1.7 or higherThe all-in renter won all 8 times, in the months right before the 2006 peak

In 2006 that was $1,879 divided by $1,056, so owning cost about 1.8 times what renting cost.

At 1.7 or higher the renter has a real shot, but only if they invest the difference between owning and renting every month and keep investing even when the stock market falls.

Think about how long you'd stay, too. In this story the buyer was behind all three renters for almost 10 years. If you might have to sell early, that really does count against buying.

What does the test say about buying today?

Using national averages, the typical home sold for about $417,500 in September 2026, and the average rate in early November 2026 was 7.18%. With 10% down, the same costs add up to about $3,625 a month. A three-bedroom house rents for about $2,100.

$3,625 divided by $2,100 comes out to about 1.7. That's in the range where the renter has a real shot. Nobody knows what prices are going to do next, and this test doesn't predict that.

After the tax break and renter's insurance, owning that house costs about $1,250 a month more than renting it. A renter who could afford the house has that much to put away, if they really put it all away.

And 1.7 is a national average, so your town could come out very differently. On that same house, rent of about $2,600 would bring it down to about 1.4. Check the rent where you live.

What would I do with all of that?

At those national averages, if you really invest that $1,250 a month, renting is a strong plan. Nobody should tell you that you're throwing money away.

If you know that money would get spent, history says a house and its forced savings have been the better plan. That's true even with bad timing.

What if you're renting because you don't have $54,000 for 10% down and closing costs? That's most renters. Add up everything the typical renter owns, subtract what they owe, and you get about $10,600, according to the Federal Reserve.

Some first-time buyers can put down as little as 3%. On that $417,500 house, that's about $12,500 before closing costs. Every dollar you put away while you rent gets you closer to that down payment.

Common questions about renting vs buying

Is renting throwing money away?

No. At the national averages in this guide, a renter who really invests the $1,250 a month they save by not buying has a strong plan. Nobody should tell you that you're throwing money away. The renters who lost in this comparison were the ones who spent the difference.

How much does a renter have to invest to come out ahead of a buyer?

In the July 2006 comparison, the renter had to invest about 38 cents of every dollar they saved by renting just to tie the buyer. That was about $11,000 up front and about $220 a month at the start, kept going for 20 years.

Is it better to rent or buy if I might move in a few years?

Selling early counts against buying. In this comparison the buyer was behind all three renters for almost 10 years, and in February 2012 it would have cost about $37,000 to sell and get out.

What is forced savings?

Part of every mortgage payment pays down the loan, and you can't skip it. It works like retirement money that comes out of your paycheck before you see it. Over 20 years the buyer's payments paid down about $90,000 they never had to decide to save.

How do I know if buying or renting makes more sense where I live?

Take the whole monthly cost to own a real listing (loan payment, property taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance and repairs) and divide it by the rent on a similar house. Under about 1.4, history is on the buyer's side. At about 1.7 or higher, the renter has a real shot if they invest the difference every month.

How much do I need for a down payment?

Some first-time buyers can put down as little as 3%. On a $417,500 house that is about $12,500 before closing costs. With 10% down and closing costs, the same house takes about $54,000.

Luke Shankula

Luke Shankula is a mortgage educator in San Diego and the host of Mortgages Made Simple on YouTube, Instagram and TikTok. He co-founded Cadre Mortgage Group with Rebecca Richardson and Marissa Dropulic. More about Luke