Is it worth buying a new construction home?

By Luke Shankula, mortgage educator and host of Mortgages Made Simple. Published November 18, 2026.

A new house can be a great buy, but the builder has a hand in almost every part of the deal, from your loan to your HOA, so the questions have to come from you. If you buy a brand new $395,000 house from a builder, your mortgage payment can go up about $470 a month in the second year, even on a fixed rate. That's the last of six hidden costs that can catch you on a new build. For each one I give you the exact question to ask the builder before you sign.

The full video runs through every step. This page has the same figures written out.

Why does the builder matter so much in a new construction deal?

With a new house, the builder usually has a hand in almost every part of the deal, from your loan to your HOA. The six hidden costs below come from that.

The first one, the builder's preferred lender, can cost or save you more than anything else on this list. I use one example house throughout, a $395,000 new build.

Is the builder's preferred lender a good deal?

The first hidden cost comes from an incentive a builder offers you for using its preferred lender. Most big builders own a mortgage company. At D.R. Horton, the biggest home builder in the country, 81% of the homes that closed in fiscal 2025 were financed by its own mortgage company. Lennar and PulteGroup report numbers in the same range.

It works a lot like buying a car at a dealership that also arranges the loan. It's convenient, but the only way to know if it's a good deal is to compare it with a loan from somewhere else.

There's a federal law on this called RESPA. Congress passed it in 1974, and one of its goals was, quote, the elimination of kickbacks or referral fees that were pushing up the cost of buying a home. In other words, people in the deal were getting paid to send you to each other, and you were the one paying for it.

A builder can offer you a discount for using its lender, but the discount has to be optional and has to be a real discount, and it can't be made up with higher costs somewhere else.

Sometimes it really is a good deal, because big builders commit a lot of money in advance to lock in lower rates for their buyers. Other times you're shown a lower rate or a big credit, but the reality is you're paying for it. Here's the example on the $395,000 house, with 5% down.

The builder's lender against another lender
ItemAmount
Amount you'd borrowAbout $375,000
The builder's lender7.4% plus $10,000 toward your closing costs
Another lender7% with no credit
What the lower rate savesAbout $100 a month
Time to make up the $10,000About 100 months, a little over eight years

If you'd likely sell or refinance within eight years, the builder's credit wins. If you keep the loan longer, the lower rate wins.

So get an official Loan Estimate from the builder's lender and from at least one other lender, and ask the builder what the incentive is worth if you use your own. My down payment guide covers the 5% down used in this example.

How much of the builder's incentive can your loan actually use?

The second hidden cost is the incentive your loan can't use. In October 2026, about two out of three builders were using incentives, and 43% were cutting prices, according to the National Association of Home Builders.

Every loan type caps how much the seller or builder can pay toward your costs.

What the seller or builder can pay toward your costs
Loan typeCap
Conventional, less than 10% down3% of the price
FHAUp to 6%
VACertain seller concessions capped at 4%

On a $395,000 house with 5% down, 3% is $11,850. So if the builder advertises $20,000 in incentives, only about $11,850 of it can go toward your closing costs, and the rest only helps you if it comes off the price. My FHA vs conventional guide covers how those two loans differ.

So ask the builder to split the incentive the way your loan can use it, between closing costs, a lower rate and a lower price, and get that split in writing.

Can lot premiums and upgrades make the appraisal come in low?

The third hidden cost is in the price of the house itself, and you might not find out until the lender checks what the house is actually worth. The price you see advertised is typically the starting price for the plain version of the house. Then you pay more for a better lot, like a corner or a bigger yard, and more for upgrades like nicer flooring, cabinets and a better kitchen.

How the $395,000 price adds up, and what the appraiser found
ItemAmount
Starting price$355,000
Corner lot$12,000
Flooring, cabinets and kitchen$28,000
Price you pay$395,000
Appraisal in my example$382,000
Gap that comes from your pocket$13,000

Before the lender approves your loan, it sends an appraiser to check what the house is actually worth, and the appraiser doesn't just copy the builder's price. Most regular mortgages follow a rule set by a company called Fannie Mae. In a new neighborhood, those rules have the appraiser compare your house with sales inside the neighborhood and at least one from outside it.

Say the appraisal comes in at $382,000 because a buyer down the street wouldn't pay full price for every upgrade. The lender works from the lower number, so that $13,000 has to come from your pocket unless the builder lowers the price.

So ask what recent buyers paid for the same floor plan, put your upgrade money into things that are hard to change later, and ask how the contract handles a low appraisal.

Who runs the HOA on a new construction home?

The fourth hidden cost is a monthly bill the builder sets before you ever get a vote. In a new neighborhood the builder usually runs the Homeowners Association at first. About two out of three new single-family homes started in 2024 were built inside an HOA.

Until enough homes are sold, the builder controls the board. In Florida, for example, owners don't take majority control until three months after 90% of the lots have been sold. That means the first budget and the first dues are set by the builder while still trying to sell homes. If the builder is covering some of the costs to keep the dues low, the dues can go up once the owners take over.

So ask for the HOA budget, whether the builder is paying any of it, when owners take control, and how much of the dues go into savings for future repairs.

Do you need an inspection on a brand new house?

The fifth hidden cost is skipping the inspection, and on a new house the most important one happens before the walls go up.

In 1992, Hurricane Andrew tore through South Miami-Dade. Afterward, the Miami Herald went through the damage and the inspection records, and it found that newer houses had held up worse than older ones. The paper won the Pulitzer Prize for showing how lax zoning, inspections and building codes had added to the destruction. Florida's building rules got a lot stronger after that, but the lesson still applies to every new house. A city inspection checks that the work meets the minimum code, and a lot of what goes wrong is about how carefully it was built.

A pre-drywall inspection is your own inspector walking the house after the framing, plumbing, wiring and ducts are in and before insulation and drywall cover them up. If something's wrong at that stage, it's a quick fix. After the wall is closed, it's hidden and gone forever.

So before you sign, make sure the contract lets your own inspector in, and book a pre-drywall inspection and a final one before closing.

Why can your payment go up in the second year of a new build?

The last hidden cost is the one I started this video with. Your payment can go up about $470 a month in the second year, even on a fixed rate, after you've already moved in. It comes from the first property tax bill.

In states like North Carolina and Florida, the county values your property based on what was there on January 1st. If your house is still being built on January 1st, the first tax bill can be for the lot or for a half-built house.

I used Holly Springs, North Carolina, outside of Raleigh, where the county and town tax rates add up to about 0.88% of the value a year.

How the first tax bill becomes a $470 jump
StepPer yearPer month
Lot valued at $75,000$660$55
House valued at $395,000$3,480$290
Increase from the lot to the house$235
Escrow shortage spread over 12 months$2,800$235
Year-two increase$470

If the lot alone is valued at $75,000, the first bill is about $660 for the year, which is about $55 a month. Once the county values the finished house at the $395,000 you paid, the bill is about $3,480 a year, which is about $290 a month. That's about $235 a month more.

But if your mortgage company was only setting aside $55 a month for the taxes, its escrow account now comes up about $2,800 short when the full bill arrives. Federal rules let them spread that shortage over 12 months, which is about another $235 a month. So $235 plus $235 is about $470 a month more for that year, and after that it settles at about $235 more than where you started.

That's one town's rate, so your county's jump could be smaller or bigger. Ask your lender whether the tax in your payment estimate is for the empty lot or the finished house. If it's the lot, have them run it on the finished house before you sign, so the payment you plan around is the one you'll actually have in year two. My guide on how much mortgage you can afford covers the monthly payment itself.

What does a builder's warranty cover?

A lot of builders use a 1-2-10 warranty, which is one year on workmanship, two years on systems like plumbing and wiring, and 10 years on major structural defects.

So put a reminder on your calendar for month 11, walk the house, and send the builder a written list before that first year runs out.

What should you ask the builder before you sign?

A new house can be a great buy, but the builder has a hand in almost every part of the deal, so the questions have to come from you.

The question to ask on each hidden cost
Hidden costWhat to ask or do
The builder's lenderGet a Loan Estimate from the builder's lender and one other lender, and ask what the incentive is worth if you use your own.
The incentive your loan can't useAsk the builder to split the incentive between closing costs, a lower rate and a lower price, in writing.
Lot premiums and upgradesAsk what recent buyers paid for the same floor plan, and how the contract handles a low appraisal.
The HOAAsk for the HOA budget, whether the builder is paying any of it, when owners take control, and how much goes into savings for repairs.
The inspectionMake sure the contract lets your own inspector in, and book a pre-drywall and a final inspection.
The first tax billAsk whether the tax in your payment estimate is for the empty lot or the finished house.

If you also want to know which kinds of houses can stop your loan before you make an offer, my guide on types of houses to avoid buying covers seven of them.

Common questions about buying new construction

Is it worth buying new construction?

A new house can be a great buy, but the builder has a hand in almost every part of the deal, from your loan to your HOA. So the questions have to come from you. I walk through six hidden costs that can catch you on a new build, and each one has a question to ask the builder before you sign.

Should I use the builder's preferred lender?

Maybe. Sometimes it really is a good deal, because big builders commit a lot of money in advance to lock in lower rates for their buyers. Other times you're shown a lower rate or a big credit and you're paying for it. Get an official Loan Estimate from the builder's lender and from at least one other lender, and ask the builder what the incentive is worth if you use your own.

Why can I only use part of the builder incentive?

Every loan type caps how much the seller or builder can pay toward your costs. On a conventional loan with less than 10% down it's 3% of the price, FHA allows up to 6%, and VA caps certain seller concessions at 4%. On a $395,000 house with 5% down, 3% is $11,850, so on a $20,000 incentive the rest only helps if it comes off the price.

Can a new house appraise for less than the price?

Yes. The advertised price covers the plain version of the house plus any lot premium and upgrades, and the appraiser doesn't just copy the builder's price. In my example the price was $395,000 and the appraisal came in at $382,000, so the $13,000 difference had to come from the buyer unless the builder lowered the price.

Do I need an inspection on a brand new house?

Yes. A city inspection checks that the work meets the minimum code, and a lot of what goes wrong is about how carefully the house was built. I recommend a pre-drywall inspection and a final one before closing, and your contract has to let your own inspector in.

Why can my payment go up in year two on a new build?

In some states, including North Carolina and Florida, the county values your property based on what was there on January 1st. If your house is still being built then, the first tax bill can be for the lot. In my Holly Springs, North Carolina example, the payment went up about $470 a month in year two, and then settled at about $235 more than where it started.

What does a builder's warranty usually cover?

A lot of builders use a 1-2-10 warranty, which is one year on workmanship, two years on systems like plumbing and wiring, and 10 years on major structural defects. I suggest putting a reminder on your calendar for month 11, walking the house, and sending the builder a written list before that first year runs out.

Sources

The figures in this guide come from the video above, which uses these sources.

  • D.R. Horton and Lennar FY2025 10-Ks
  • PulteGroup Q2 2025 earnings release
  • NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (Oct 2026)
  • Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, B4-1.3-08 and B2-1.2-01
  • RESPA and Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.2 and 1024.17
  • NAHB analysis of the Census Survey of Construction (2024)
  • Fla. Stat. 720.307
  • Pulitzer Prizes, Miami Herald (1993)
  • N.C. Gen. Stat. 105-285

More guides

See all guides

Luke Shankula

Luke Shankula is a mortgage educator in San Diego and the host of Mortgages Made Simple on YouTube, Instagram and TikTok. He co-founded Cadre Mortgage Group with Rebecca Richardson and Marissa Dropulic. He has held his mortgage license since 2017 (NMLS #1446932). More about Luke